Geometric Event Finding Hands-On Lesson, using MEX

November 20, 2017

Overview

This lesson illustrates how the Geometry Finder (GF) subsystem of the SpiceyPy Toolkit can be used to find time intervals when specified geometric conditions are satisfied.

In this lesson the student is asked to construct a program that finds the time intervals, within a specified time range, when the Mars Express Orbiter (MEX) is visible from the DSN station DSS-14. Possible occultation of the spacecraft by Mars is to be considered.

References

This section lists SPICE documents referred to in this lesson.

In some cases the lesson explanations also refer to the information provided in the meta-data area of the kernels used in the lesson examples. It is especially true in case of the FK and IK files, which often contain comprehensive descriptions of the frames, instrument FOVs, etc. Since both FK and IK are text kernels, the information provided in them can be viewed using any text editor, while the meta information provided in binary kernels – SPKs and CKs – can be viewed using "commnt" or" spacit" utility programs located in "cspice/exe" of Toolkit installation tree.

The following SPICE tutorials serve as references for the discussions in this lesson:

Name              Lesson steps/functions it describes
----------------  -----------------------------------------------
Time              Time Conversion
SCLK and LSK      Time Conversion
SPK               Obtaining Ephemeris Data
Frames            Reference Frames
Using Frames      Reference Frames
PCK               Planetary Constants Data
Lunar-Earth PCK   Lunar and Earth Orientation Data
GF                The SPICE Geometry Finder (GF) subsystem

These tutorials are available from the NAIF ftp server at JPL: https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/naif/tutorials.html

Required Readings

The Required Reading documents are provided with the Toolkit and are located under the "cspice/doc" directory in the CSPICE Toolkit installation tree.

Name             Lesson steps/functions that it describes
---------------  -----------------------------------------
cells.req        Cell/window initialization
frames.req       Using reference frames
gf.req           The SPICE geometry finder (GF) subsystem
kernel.req       Loading SPICE kernels
naif_ids.req     Body and reference frame names
pck.req          Obtaining planetary constants data
spk.req          Computing positions and velocities
time.req         UTC to ET time conversion
windows.req      The SPICE window data type

The Permuted Index

Another useful document distributed with the Toolkit is the permuted index. This is located under the "cspice/doc" directory in the C installation tree.

This text document provides a simple mechanism by which users can discover which SpiceyPy functions perform functions of interest, as well as the names of the source files that contain these functions.

SpiceyPy API Documentation

A SpiceyPy function's parameters specification is available using the built-in Python help system.

For example, the Python help function

describes the str2et function's parameters, while the str2et documentation describes extensively the str2et functionality.

Kernels Used

The following kernels are used in examples provided in this lesson:

#  FILE NAME                      TYPE DESCRIPTION
-- ------------------------------ ---- ------------------------------
1  de405xs.bsp                    SPK  Planetary ephemeris SPK,
                                       subsetted to cover only time
                                       range of interest
2  earthstns_itrf93_050714.bsp    SPK  DSN station SPK
3  earth_topo_050714.tf           FK   DSN station frame definitions
4  earth_000101_060525_060303.bpc PCK  Binary PCK for Earth
5  naif0008.tls                   LSK  Generic LSK
6  ORMM__040501000000_00076XS.BSP SPK  MEX Orbiter trajectory SPK,
                                       subsetted to cover only time
                                       range of interest
7  pck00008.tpc                   PCK  Generic PCK
8  mars_lowres.bds                DSK  Low-resolution Mars DSK

These SPICE kernels are included in the lesson package available from the NAIF server at JPL: https://naif.jpl.nasa.gov/pub/naif/misc/toolkit_docs_N0067/Lessons/

SpiceyPy Modules Used

This section provides a complete list of the functions and kernels that are suggested for usage in each of the exercises in this lesson. (You may wish to not look at this list unless/until you "get stuck" while working on your own.)

CHAPTER EXERCISE   FUNCTIONS        NON-VOID         KERNELS
------- ---------  ---------------  ---------------  ----------
   1    viewpr     spiceypy.furnsh  spiceypy.rpd     1-7
                   spiceypy.wninsd  spiceypy.str2et
                   spiceypy.gfposc  spiceypy.timout
                   spiceypy.unload  spiceypy.wncard
                                    spiceypy.wnfetd

   2    visibl     spiceypy.furnsh  spiceypy.rpd     1-8
                   spiceypy.wninsd  spiceypy.str2et
                   spiceypy.gfposc  spiceypy.timout
                   spiceypy.gfoclt  spiceypy.wndifd
                   spiceypy.unload  spiceypy.wncard
                                    spiceypy.wnfetd

        extra (*)  spiceypy.gfdist  spiceypy.repmc   1,5-7
                   spiceypy.kclear  spiceypy.repmf


   (*) Additional APIs and kernels used in Extra Credit tasks.

Use the Python built-in help system on the various functions listed above for the API parameters' description, and refer to the headers of their corresponding CSPICE versions for detailed interface specifications.

Find View Periods

Task Statement

Write a program that finds the set of time intervals, within the time range 2004 MAY 2 TDB to 2004 MAY 6 TDB, when the Mars Express Orbiter (MEX) is visible from the DSN station DSS-14. These time intervals are frequently called "view periods."

The spacecraft is considered visible if its apparent position (that is, its position corrected for light time and stellar aberration) has elevation of at least 6 degrees in the topocentric reference frame DSS-14_TOPO. In this exercise, we ignore the possibility of occultation of the spacecraft by Mars.

Use a search step size that ensures that no view periods of duration 5 minutes or longer will be missed by the search.

Display the start and stop times of these intervals using TDB calendar dates and millisecond precision.

Learning Goals

Exposure to SPICE GF event finding routines. Familiarity with SPICE windows and routines that manipulate them. Exposure to SPICE time parsing and output formatting routines.

Approach

Solution steps

A possible solution could consist of the following steps:

Preparation:

  1. Decide what SPICE kernels are necessary. Use the SPICE summary tool BRIEF to examine the coverage of the binary kernels and verify the availability of required data.

  2. Create a meta-kernel listing the SPICE kernels to be loaded. (Hint: consult a programming example tutorial, or the Introduction to Kernels tutorial, for a reminder of how to do this.)

    Name the meta-kernel 'viewpr.tm'.

Next, write a program that performs the following steps:

  1. Use spiceypy.furnsh to load the meta-kernel.

  2. Create confinement and output SpiceyPy windows using spiceypy.cell_double.

  3. Insert the given time bounds into the confinement window using spiceypy.wninsd.

  4. Select a step size for searching for visibility state transitions: in this case, each target rise or set event is a state transition.

    The step size must be large enough so the search proceeds with reasonable speed, but small enough so that no visibility transition events---that is, target rise or set events---are missed.

  5. Use the GF routine spiceypy.gfposc to find the window of times, within the confinement window, during which the MEX spacecraft is above the elevation limit as seen from DSN station DSS-14, in the reference frame DSS-14_TOPO.

    Use light time and stellar aberration corrections for the apparent position of the spacecraft as seen from the station.

  6. Fetch and display the contents of the result window. Use spiceypy.wnfetd to extract from the result window the start and stop times of each time interval. Display each of the intervals in the result window as a pair of start and stop times. Express each time as a TDB calendar date using the routine spiceypy.timout.

You may find it useful to consult the references listed above. In particular, the header of the SPICE GF function spiceypy.gfposc contains pertinent documentation.

Solution

Solution Meta-Kernel

The meta-kernel we created for the solution to this exercise is named 'viewpr.tm'. Its contents follow:

Solution Code

The example program below shows one possible solution.

Solution Sample Output

Numerical results shown for this example may differ across platforms since the results depend on the SPICE kernels used as input and on the host platform's arithmetic implementation.

Execute the program. The output is:

Inputs for target visibility search:

   Target                       = MEX
   Observation surface location = DSS-14
   Observer's reference frame   = DSS-14_TOPO
   Elevation limit (degrees)    = 6.000000
   Aberration correction        = CN+S
   Step size (seconds)          = 300.000000
   Start time                   = 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
   Stop time                    = 2004 MAY 06 00:00:00.000 (TDB)

Visibility times of MEX as seen from DSS-14:

Visibility or window start time:  2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
Visibility stop time:             2004 MAY 02 05:35:03.096 (TDB)

Visibility start time:            2004 MAY 02 16:09:14.078 (TDB)
Visibility stop time:             2004 MAY 03 05:33:57.257 (TDB)

Visibility start time:            2004 MAY 03 16:08:02.279 (TDB)
Visibility stop time:             2004 MAY 04 05:32:50.765 (TDB)

Visibility start time:            2004 MAY 04 16:06:51.259 (TDB)
Visibility stop time:             2004 MAY 05 05:31:43.600 (TDB)

Visibility start time:            2004 MAY 05 16:05:40.994 (TDB)
Visibility or window stop time:   2004 MAY 06 00:00:00.000 (TDB)

Find Times when Target is Visible

Task Statement

Extend the program of the previous chapter to find times when the MEX orbiter is:

  • Above the elevation limit in the DSS-14_TOPO topocentric reference frame.

  • And not occulted by Mars.

Finding time intervals that satisfy the second condition requires a search for occultations of the spacecraft by Mars. Perform this search twice: once using an ellipsoidal shape model for Mars, and once using a DSK shape model.

Compute the final results twice as well, using the results of both occultation searches.

For each of the two shape model cases, store the set of time intervals when the spacecraft is visible in a SpiceyPy window. We'll call this the "result window."

Display each of the intervals in each result window as a pair of start and stop times. Express each time as a TDB calendar date using the same format as in the previous program.

Learning Goals

Familiarity with the GF occultation finding routine spiceypy.gfoclt. Experience with Digital Shape Kernel (DSK) shape models. Further experience with the SpiceyPy window functions.

Approach

Solution steps

A possible solution would consist of the following steps:

  1. Use the meta-kernel from the previous chapter as the starting point. Add more kernels to it as needed.

    Name the meta-kernel 'visibl.tm'.

  2. Include the code from the program of the previous chapter in a new source file; modify this code to create the new program.

  3. Your program will need additional windows to capture the results of occultation searches performed using both ellipsoidal and DSK shape models. Additional windows will be needed to compute the set differences of the elevation search ("view period") window and each of the occultation search windows. Further details are provided below.

    Create additional output SpiceyPy windows using spiceypy.cell_double.

  4. The remaining steps can be performed twice: once using an ellipsoidal shape model for Mars, and once using a DSK Mars shape model. Alternatively, two copies of the entire solution program can be created: one for each shape model.

  5. Search for occultations of the MEX orbiter as seen from DSS-14 using spiceypy.gfoclt. Use as the confinement window for this search the result window from the elevation search performed by spiceypy.gfposc.

    Since occultations occur when the apparent MEX spacecraft position is behind the apparent figure of Mars, light time correction must be performed for the occultation search. To improve accuracy of the occultation state determination, use "converged Newtonian" light time correction.

  6. Use the SpiceyPy window subtraction routine spiceypy.wndifd to subtract the window of times when the spacecraft is occulted from the window of times when the spacecraft is above the elevation limit. The difference window is the final result.

  7. Modify the code to display the contents of the difference window.

This completes the assignment.

Solution

Solution Meta-Kernel

The meta-kernel we created for the solution to this exercise is named 'visibl.tm'. Its contents follow:

Solution Code

Solution Sample Output

Numerical results shown for this example may differ across platforms since the results depend on the SPICE kernels used as input and on the host platform's arithmetic implementation.

Execute the program. The output is:

Inputs for target visibility search:

   Target                       = MEX
   Observation surface location = DSS-14
   Observer's reference frame   = DSS-14_TOPO
   Blocking body                = MARS
   Blocker's reference frame    = IAU_MARS
   Elevation limit (degrees)    = 6.000000
   Aberration correction        = CN+S
   Step size (seconds)          = 300.000000
   Start time                   = 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 TDB
   Stop time                    = 2004 MAY 06 00:00:00.000 TDB

 Searching using ellipsoid target shape model...
 Done.
 Searching using DSK target shape model...
 Done.

Visibility start and stop times of MEX as seen from DSS-14
using both ellipsoidal and DSK target shape models:

 Ell: 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 TDB : 2004 MAY 02 04:49:30.827 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 TDB : 2004 MAY 02 04:49:32.645 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 02 16:09:14.078 TDB : 2004 MAY 02 20:00:22.514 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 02 16:09:14.078 TDB : 2004 MAY 02 20:00:23.980 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 02 21:01:38.222 TDB : 2004 MAY 03 03:35:42.256 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 02 21:01:43.195 TDB : 2004 MAY 03 03:35:44.140 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 03 04:36:42.484 TDB : 2004 MAY 03 05:33:57.257 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 03 04:36:46.856 TDB : 2004 MAY 03 05:33:57.257 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 03 16:08:02.279 TDB : 2004 MAY 03 18:46:26.013 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 03 16:08:02.279 TDB : 2004 MAY 03 18:46:27.306 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 03 19:46:54.618 TDB : 2004 MAY 04 02:21:44.562 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 03 19:46:59.723 TDB : 2004 MAY 04 02:21:46.574 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 04 03:21:56.347 TDB : 2004 MAY 04 05:32:50.765 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 04 03:22:00.850 TDB : 2004 MAY 04 05:32:50.765 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 04 16:06:51.259 TDB : 2004 MAY 04 17:32:25.809 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 04 16:06:51.259 TDB : 2004 MAY 04 17:32:27.118 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 04 18:32:05.975 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 01:07:48.264 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 04 18:32:11.046 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 01:07:50.061 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 05 02:07:11.601 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 05:31:43.600 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 05 02:07:16.241 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 05:31:43.600 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 05 16:05:40.994 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 16:18:35.560 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 05 16:05:40.994 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 16:18:36.994 TDB

 Ell: 2004 MAY 05 17:17:27.717 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 23:54:04.672 TDB
 DSK: 2004 MAY 05 17:17:32.375 TDB : 2004 MAY 05 23:54:06.221 TDB

Extra Credit

In this "extra credit" section you will be presented with more complex tasks, aimed at improving your understanding of the geometry event finding subsystem and particularly the spiceypy.gfposc and spiceypy.gfdist functions.

These "extra credit" tasks are provided as task statements, and unlike the regular tasks, no approach or solution source code is provided. In the next section, you will find the numeric solutions to the questions asked in these tasks.

Task statements

  1. Write a program that finds the times, within the time range 2004 MAY 2 TDB to 2004 MAY 6 TDB, when the MEX spacecraft crosses Mars' equator. Display the results using TDB calendar dates and millisecond precision.

  2. Write a program that finds the times, within the time range 2004 MAY 2 TDB to 2004 MAY 6 TDB, when the MEX spacecraft is at periapsis. Display the results using TDB calendar dates and millisecond precision.

  3. Write a program that finds the times, within the time range 2004 MAY 2 TDB to 2004 MAY 6 TDB, when the MEX spacecraft is at apoapsis. Display the results using TDB calendar dates and millisecond precision.

Solutions

  1. Solution for the equator crossing search, using spiceypy.gfposc for the MEX spacecraft latitude in the Mars body-fixed frame equal to 0 degrees:

    Inputs for equator crossing search:
    
       Target                       = MEX
       Observer                     = MARS
       Observer's reference frame   = IAU_MARS
       Latitude limit (degrees)     = 0.000000
       Aberration correction        = NONE
       Step size (seconds)          = 300.000000
       Start time                   = 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
       Stop time                    = 2004 MAY 06 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
    
    MEX MARS equator crossing times:
    
     Equator crossing or start time:  2004 MAY 02 05:00:08.334 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 02 06:15:13.074 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 02 12:35:14.856 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 02 13:50:09.161 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 02 20:10:24.439 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 02 21:25:10.344 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 03 03:45:26.758 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 03 05:00:04.086 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 03 11:20:32.419 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 03 12:34:57.968 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 03 18:55:34.883 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 03 20:09:53.063 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 04 02:30:35.509 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 04 03:44:42.753 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 04 10:05:41.638 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 04 11:19:38.397 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 04 17:40:41.405 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 04 18:54:31.413 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 05 01:15:45.967 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 05 02:29:25.294 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 05 08:50:53.931 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 05 10:04:26.915 (TDB)
     Equator crossing time:           2004 MAY 05 16:25:58.350 (TDB)
     Equator crossing or stop time:   2004 MAY 05 17:39:23.889 (TDB)
    
  2. Solution for the periapsis search, using spiceypy.gfdist for the MEX spacecraft distance from Mars at a local minimum:

    Inputs for periapsis search:
    
       Target                       = MEX
       Observer                     = MARS
       Aberration correction        = NONE
       Step size (seconds)          = 300.000000
       Start time                   = 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
       Stop time                    = 2004 MAY 06 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
    
    MEX periapsis times:
    
     Periapsis or start time:         2004 MAY 02 05:57:51.000 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 02 13:32:43.325 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 02 21:07:41.124 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 03 04:42:30.648 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 03 12:17:21.143 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 03 19:52:12.267 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 04 03:26:57.755 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 04 11:01:49.826 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 04 18:36:38.448 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 05 02:11:28.558 (TDB)
     Periapsis time:                  2004 MAY 05 09:46:26.309 (TDB)
     Periapsis or end time:           2004 MAY 05 17:21:18.875 (TDB)
    
  3. Solution for the apoapsis search, using spiceypy.gfdist for the MEX spacecraft distance from Mars at a local maximum:

    Inputs for apoapsis search:
    
       Target                       = MEX
       Observer                     = MARS
       Aberration correction        = NONE
       Step size (seconds)          = 300.000000
       Start time                   = 2004 MAY 02 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
       Stop time                    = 2004 MAY 06 00:00:00.000 (TDB)
    
    MEX apoapsis times:
    
     Apoapsis or start time:          2004 MAY 02 02:10:24.948 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 02 09:45:19.189 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 02 17:20:14.194 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 03 00:55:07.633 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 03 08:29:57.890 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 03 16:04:48.524 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 03 23:39:36.745 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 04 07:14:25.662 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 04 14:49:15.904 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 04 22:24:05.351 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 05 05:58:59.270 (TDB)
     Apoapsis time:                   2004 MAY 05 13:33:54.433 (TDB)
     Apoapsis or stop time:           2004 MAY 05 21:08:50.211 (TDB)